Concerto Project: Compose an Allegro

In this project you compose the first, fast movement of a concerto in Baroque style, for a solo instrument, strings and basso continuo, in a key you choose. Length: about 60–90 bars. Agree your solo instrument with me before Step 2.

You already have everything you need. Vivaldi’s RV 152 is built from six patterns that you have played at the keyboard: pedal on ①, leaping bass ↓5 ↑4, pedal on ⑤, the set of cadences, the double cadence and the evaded cadence (Concerto: Vivaldi, RV 152). Your movement uses the same patterns, in the same order, in your own key, and it adds a soloist.

The ensemble

Write your score on five staves, from the top:

  1. Solo (your instrument)
  2. Violin I
  3. Violin II
  4. Viola
  5. Cello (basso continuo), with figures. The harpsichord plays from this line; you do not write its part out.

This is Vivaldi’s own layout. In Spring (The Four Seasons, Op. 8 no. 1) the parts are Violino Principale (the soloist), Violino Primo, Violino Secondo, Alto Viola and Organo e Violoncello.

In the ritornellos, the soloist plays with Violin I: the same notes in the same rhythm. The soloist is part of the tutti. In Spring the two parts are identical for the whole opening ritornello, until the bar marked Solo. Write the ritornello once for Violin I, then copy it into the solo staff.

In the solos, the soloist plays alone. Violin I rests or joins the accompaniment.

If your soloist is not a violin, it still doubles Violin I in the ritornellos. Where Violin I goes below your instrument’s range, take that passage up an octave or rest. If your soloist is a low instrument (cello, bassoon), ask me first.

The drama: chorus and protagonist

Heinrich Christoph Koch (1793) compared the concerto to the tragedy of the ancients. The soloist is like an actor who expresses feelings to the chorus, and the orchestra answers with short interjections. Use that picture when you plan:

  • The full orchestra (Tutti, forte) plays the ritornello: it states the key and confirms each arrival.
  • The soloist (Solo, piano) speaks in the episodes between ritornellos. The texture thins and the soloist keeps the music moving.

RV 152 has no soloist, but it makes the same contrast with texture alone. Its quiet sections are marked Piano and Senza Cembalo (no harpsichord), and the full group returns, forte, at the real close that ends each quiet section. In your movement, give those quiet sections to the soloist. You may drop the harpsichord there too.

Real closes and local closes

Everything in the plan depends on where the music really closes.

A real close (see Discant Clausula in the Bass for the contrast):

  • ⑤–① in the bass (the bass clausula);
  • the melody lands on Do or Mi on the downbeat and holds it, with a discant clausula (Ti–Do) or a tenor clausula (Re–Do), or a double cadence for the weightiest ones;
  • the next section begins on it: at the end of a solo the full group comes in (Tutti, f); at the end of a ritornello the solo enters.

Use a real close mostly at the end of a section: most ritornellos and solos end with one, and real closes rarely come anywhere else. At the end of a solo the full group comes in (Tutti, f); at the end of a ritornello the solo enters. RV 152: ritornellos 19→20, 34→35, 46→47, 69→70, 79→80; solos 28→29, 54→55, 86→87; end 92→93. Bach, BWV 1042: the opening ritornello closes in bar 11, after two evaded cadences, and the solo enters in bar 12.

Inside a section, keep the music moving. Use local or evaded closes:

  • ⑦–① in the bass (the discant clausula in the bass);
  • an empty downbeat: the bass rests on the beat and comes in after it;
  • a melody that lands on Sol, or runs on without holding;
  • the evaded cadence ⑤–④–③: the bass lands on ③, a 6 chord, so there is no close (Evaded Cadences; Eight common techniques of cadential evasion);
  • the deceptive cadence ⑤–⑥: the bass falls to ⑥, which takes a 5/3;
  • the evaded double cadence: the bass reaches ① but takes a ♭7, so the music moves on to the key a fifth below.

The plan

Follow RV 152 section by section; the workbook has the planning sheet. Your home key is ①. Your second key is ⑤ in a major key, or the relative major in a minor key. Then go to one or two contrasting keys before you come home.

SectionTextureBassEnds with
1Ritornello: openingTutti, fPedal on ①: an opening formula (pattern 1)keeps going
2Ritornello: spinning outTutti, fLeaping bass ↓5 ↑4, with sevenths (pattern 2)keeps going
3Ritornello: pedal on ⑤Tutti, fPedal on ⑤ (pattern 3)real close (19→20); the solo enters on it
4Solo 1Solo, pSet of cadences (pattern 4)real close: tutti enters
5Tutti: on to the new keyTutti, fLeaping bass, slower or modulatingreal close in key 2 (34→35)
6Ritornello in key 2Tutti, fPedal on ① of key 2keeps going
7Spinning out in key 2Tutti, fLeaping bass ↓5 ↑4keeps going
8Double cadence in key 2Tutti, fPedal on ⑤ under 5/3, 6/4, 7/5 (pattern 5)real close (46→47); the solo enters on it
9Solo 2Solo, pSet of cadences in key 2real close: tutti enters
10TuttiTutti, fPedal on ① of key 2keeps going
11Evaded cadencesTutti or solo⑤–④–③ into one or two contrasting keys (pattern 6)no close
12Ritornello in a contrasting keyTutti, fPedal on ①, then a short cadence onto ⑤ of the home keyreal close (69→70) = ⑤ of home
13Ritornello: returnTutti, fPedal on ① in the home keykeeps going
14Pedal on ⑤Tutti, fPedal on ⑤; may stop on a fermata for a short solo lead-inreal close (79→80); the solo enters on it
15Solo 3Solo, pSet of cadences in the home keyreal close: tutti enters
16Final cadence and pedal on ①Tutti, fBass clausula, then pedal on ①: a quiescenza works wellreal close (92→93), end
The sixteen-section plan

This is the same skeleton as the RV 152 table: your analysis of RV 152 is the plan you fill in.

Bass motions: which one where

Each section of the movement has a job. Choose a bass motion that does that job. Usual is what Vivaldi does in RV 152; also works is yours to try. Rows = the rows of the planning sheet below; the fillable workbook (the button above) holds the same choices in each row’s menu.

Job of the sectionRowsUsualAlso works
Set the key1, 6, 10, 12, 13pedal on ①; opening formula over ①an opening formula (4 chords, major or minor); Rule of the Octave up from ①
Spin out2, 7leaping bass ↓5 ↑4, with sevenths or plainleaping bass ↓3 ↑2 (6/3 or 6/5 chords); stepwise descent with 4/2–6; Rule of the Octave down
Move to key 25leaping bass ↓5 ↑4, modulatingany spinning-out motion that stops on ⑤ of key 2; Rule of the Octave in key 2 up to ⑤
Stand on the dominant, then close3, 8, 14pedal on ⑤; double cadenceRule of the Octave up or down to ⑤, then hold it
Solo4, 9, 15set of cadencesa spinning-out motion in a thinner texture, then a set of cadences
Pass through keys without closing11evaded cadence ⑤–④–③, chaineddeceptive cadence ⑤–⑥; evaded double cadence; leaping bass ↓5 ↑4 aimed at the new key; local closes only
End16⑤–①, then a quiescenza⑤–①, then a plain pedal on ①; a double cadence, then a pedal on ①

The end of a section is a separate choice. Whatever the bass does in the middle, the last bars follow the “Close at the end” column of the planning sheet: a real close = ⑤–① in the bass with the melody landing on Do or Mi (section 2, above); keeps going or no close = one of the local or evaded closes above, or no cadence at all.

What each bass motion does

Bass motionThe bass, and the chords above itWhere to look
Opening formulaa short formula of four chords that states the key at the start; major and minor forms, or over a held ①.Unit 3-2
Pedal on ①holds or repeats ①; the chords move above it.Oct 14 handout: 1
Quiescenzaa closing pedal on ①, with ♭7–6–♮7–8 above it.Unit 3-2
Leaping bass ↓5 ↑4down a fifth, up a fourth, again and again. With sevenths: a 7 on every chord, prepared in the chord before, falling by step. Plain: 5/3 chords. Modulating: it stops on ⑤ of the new key.Oct 14 handout: 2; Unit 5-1-2
Leaping bass ↓3 ↑2down a third, up a step: the pair sinks by step. 6/3 or 6/5 chords.Unit 5-1-2
Stepwise descent with 4/2–6the bass falls by step; a 4/2 on each note, which becomes a 6 when the bass moves down.Unit 5-1-2
Rule of the Octavethe bass walks the scale, up or down, with the standard chord on each degree.Unit 4-1
Pedal on ⑤holds ⑤; 7 with the raised third alternates with 6/4. Then ⑤–①.Oct 14 handout: 3
Double cadence⑤ held under 5/3 → 6/4 → 7/5 → 6/4 → 7/5, then ①.Oct 14 handout: 5; Unit 3-1
Set of cadencesshort cadences one after another; the bass often rests on the downbeat. Most arrivals are local (⑦–①, empty downbeat); the last is the real close.Oct 14 handout: 4
Evaded cadence ⑤–④–③⑤ (5/3) → ④ (4/2) → ③ (6): lands on the new key’s tonic as a 6 chord, so no close. Chain it to pass through keys.Oct 14 handout: 6; Unit 5-1-2
Deceptive cadence ⑤–⑥⑤ → ⑥ with a 5/3: the bass steps past ①.Unit 5-1-2
Evaded double cadencethe bass reaches ①, but ① takes a ♭7 and moves on to the key a fifth below.Unit 5-1-2

Character and diminution

Use the Guide to Diminution and its gallery. Decorate only after the framework is right (“Before you decorate: add dissonance over long bass notes”).

  • Tutti (the chorus): bold and simple. Leaps through the chord, strong downbeats, repeated notes (Model 2), octave leaps in the bass (Model 3), arpeggiation (Model 6).
  • Solo (the protagonist): more varied diminution than the tutti: scales and runs (Model 5) and arpeggios (Model 6), as in RV 152, plus neighbours, mordents and trills (Model 4), “Repeat with lower neighbor” (Additional Model 1), “Leap out of a suspension” (Additional Model 4).
  • Accelerate through a solo: start in eighths, settle into sixteenths in the sequence, and finish with a scale run into the cadence (goal-oriented diminutions, Model 5), with a trill on the penultimate note of the real close.
  • Keep the structural notes on the strong beats. The note of the chord (from the figures or the Rule of the Octave) goes on the beat, and the decoration goes between.
  • Choose a palette and reuse it. Label the ritornello’s diminution X and the cadence diminution Y. Use the same X and Y every time those sections return, transposed to the new key, as Vivaldi does.

Steps and due dates

StepWhat you hand inDue
1Bass plan. The bass with figures, every section labelled Tutti f / Solo p, every real close marked, and the planning sheet filled in.Mon Nov 2
2Ritornellos, all parts. Write the opening ritornello (rows 1–3) in full score on all five staves: solo and Violin I together on your theme X, Violin II and viola filled in from the figures, the cello with its figures. Then copy it into every key where the tutti returns (rows 5–8, 10, 12–14, 16). Shorten each return as your plan says, and change its last bars so that it closes, or keeps going, where the plan says. Row 5 is your spinning-out (row 2), changed so that it stops on ⑤ of key 2. Leave the solo sections empty for now, except for the bass.Wed Nov 4
3Solo sections. Write the solos (rows 4, 9, 15) and the evaded cadences (row 11): the solo line over your bass, piano, with a light accompaniment (the continuo alone, or a few held notes in the strings).Mon Nov 9
4Corrections and final version. Revise Steps 2 and 3 from my comments. The complete movement, with dynamics, Tutti/Solo marks and bar numbers in every part.Mon Nov 16

Each step has a checklist in the workbook. Check your work against it before you upload.

Pages to use

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *