Imitation and Double Counterpoint

One way to construct is to use double counterpoint. This is most easily done over a pedal point or series of cadences of equal duration, but can also apply to longer progressions (as long as the progression repeats).

Use the following process:

  1. Choose a bass line with repetitions (single harmony, series of cadences, a sequence or a longer repeating progression).
  2. Fill in the upper parts of the progression without diminution:
    • In case of a pedal point arpeggiate the chord
    • In case of cadences use different clausulae – make sure that you vary them and not use the same clausula twice
    • In the case of a sequence use those that support imitation
    • In the case of a longer progression use the principles above the voices may or may not move in the shortest possible route (based on how much diminution you want to add)
  3. Create the Basic Version of your imitation: add diminutions in the various voices. Use a variety of durations to contrast the different parts, use permitted parallels (3rds, 6ths, 6/3 chords) and contrary and oblique motion.
  4. Gradually add the diminutions in a layered fashion

Imitation over a single harmony (usually tonic):

Basic Version – Single Harmony Imitation by Avner Dorman

Notice the contrary motion and the constant filling out of the harmony

Basic Version With Diminution – Single Harmony Imitation by Avner Dorman

Now enter the voices gradually:

Row, Row, Row Your Boat – Misc Traditional by Avner Dorman

And here’s an example from Bach’s invention in F major, where the first five bars consist of diminutions of the tonic triad with imitation. Notice the use of alternating durations and contrary motion followed by parallel 6ths.

Invention_No._8_in_F_Major – imitation analysis.mscz by Avner Dorman

The following table summarizes the model of thinking of imitation through double counterpoint over a figured bass. This table assumes three parts over a real bass, but it can be adjusted for any number of voices and can work with an imaginary figured bass as well (i.e., a chord progression in the background but note physically performed)

XYZ
XY
X
Figured bass progression Figured bass progression Figured bass progression

The method suggests that we write the various diminutions on top of each other first and then spread them as imitation. The main challenge is to make sure that the lines flow smoothly to create a logical melodic progression. So our goal is to make sure that the sequence X-Y-Z above sounds like a logical melody.

One way to do this is to work on the parts both vertically and horizontally at the same time.

When using pedal point bass, the upper voices will complete the harmony of the sustained chord.

When using a bass line that alternates clausulae (i.e., cadences), the upper voices will complete the remaining clausulae.

Over sequences, we will use standard patterns.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *