Adding Suspensions to a Partimento

You already know how to realize a partimento plainly: one chord on each bass note, from the figures and the Rule of the Octave. This page adds one step between the plain realization and the diminution: suspensions.

Fenaroli’s rules (Naples, 1775) name only four dissonances: the 2nd, 4th, 7th and 9th. Each one has to be prepared by a consonance and resolved to one. In other words, in a partimento the dissonances are suspensions. (The 2nd is the bass’s own suspension: the bass is tied and the upper voices move. It is not covered here.) What Fenaroli adds is a rule for where a suspension can go. You will find it in step 3.

1. The partimento

Example 1. Fenaroli, Partimento 1, with figures. The two runs marked Ut Re Mi Fa Mi Re Ut are one pattern, the Rule of the Octave up from ① to ④ and back: first in G (bars 2–3), then the same steps in D (bars 4–5). In bar 15, Fenaroli’s cadence: 5/3, 6/4, 5/4, 5/3 over one held bass note.

2. A plain realization

Example 2. Plain realization: one chord per bass note, from the figures.

Nothing here is dissonant except what the figures ask for: the 6/4/3 and 6/5 chords of the Rule of the Octave, and the cadential 6/4 in bar 9. Every suspension in this lesson starts from a realization like this one.

3. Find the places

A suspension has three stages, always in this order:

  1. Preparation: a consonant note in one chord.
  2. Dissonance: the same note, held while the bass moves, on a strong beat.
  3. Resolution: down by step to a consonance.

Whether the held note becomes a dissonance, and which one, depends only on how the bass moves. You can count it. The upper note stays where it is. When the bass rises by some number of steps, the interval gets smaller by that number; when the bass falls, it gets larger. An octave over a bass that rises a step: 8 − 1 = 7. Count steps, not interval names: a name counts both notes, so a 3rd is 2 steps, a 4th 3, a 5th 4. A 3rd held over a bass that falls a 5th: 3 + 4 = 7. If the answer is too small or too large, add or take away 7. Fenaroli’s chapters on the 4th, 7th and 9th list the moves that make a dissonance. Click a row to see one, or try your own with the buttons (circled numbers are scale degrees of the bass).

Three conditions from Fenaroli:

  • A 4th needs a bass note that takes a 5/3. It resolves to the 3rd while the 5th sounds.
  • A 7th always has its 3rd. It resolves to the 6th while the bass holds, or to the 3rd when the bass goes on up a 4th.
  • A 9th has its 3rd and 5th. It resolves to the octave while the bass holds.

“While the bass holds” matters in a quarter-note bass like this one. There is no time to resolve on the next beat, so resolve on the half-beat: dissonance on the beat, resolution on the “and”.

Three places, worked through

blue = preparation, red = dissonance, green = resolution. The numbers above the staff mark the moment of each dissonance and its resolution. Sometimes the dissonance begins in the middle of a note that is already sounding, when the bass moves under it.

Example 3a, bar 2. The bass rises a step, G to A. The alto’s G is the octave over G; held over A it becomes a 7th and resolves to F♯, the 6th that the figure 6/4/3 asks for.
Example 3b, bars 11–12. The bass goes from the leading tone to the tonic, F♯ to G. C, the 5th of the 6/5 on F♯, is held over G as a 4th and falls to B. (On the first beat of bar 11, D is held over E: the bass rose a step, so it is a 7–6.)
Example 3c, bars 9–10. The bass rises a 4th, A to D. The 7th over A, G, is held over D as a 4th and falls to F♯. This is in the alto.

Every place in this partimento

The table applied to every strong beat (beats 1 and 3) of Fenaroli 1. A place is listed only when the note to hold is in the first chord and the resolution fits the figure of the second.

Show all places (20)
BarBass (figure)Possible suspensionUsed in
1, beat 3B (6) → C (5)hold the 3rd → 9–8
2, beat 1D (♯) → G (5/3)hold the 7th → 4–3
hold the 5th → 9–8
2, beat 3G (5/3) → A (♯6/4/3)hold the octave → 7–6Ex. 5
3, beat 1B (6) → C (5/3)hold the 3rd → 9–8
3, beat 3B (6) → A (6/4/3)hold the 6th → 7–6
4, beat 3D (5/3) → E (♯6/4/3)hold the octave → 7–6Ex. 5
5, beat 1F♯ (6) → G (5/3)hold the 3rd → 9–8
5, beat 3F♯ (6) → E (♯6/4/3)hold the 6th → 7–6
6, beat 3C♯ (6/5) → D (5/3)hold the 3rd → 9–8
hold the 5th of the 6/5 → 4–3
Ex. 4, Ex. 5
7, beat 1D (5/3) → A (♯)hold the octave → 4–3Ex. 4, Ex. 5
9, beat 1G (6/5) → A (6/4)hold the 5th → 4–3Ex. 4, Ex. 5
10, beat 1A (7/♯) → D (5/3)hold the 7th → 4–3
hold the 5th → 9–8
Ex. 4
11, beat 1D (5/3) → E (6)hold the octave → 7–6Ex. 4, Ex. 5
11, beat 3E (6) → F♯ (6/5)hold the octave → 7–6Ex. 4
12, beat 1F♯ (6/5) → G (5/3)hold the 3rd → 9–8
hold the 5th of the 6/5 → 4–3
Ex. 4
12, beat 3G (5/3) → A (6/4/3)hold the octave → 7–6Ex. 5
13, beat 1B (6) → C (6/5)hold the octave → 7–6
13, beat 3D (5/3) → E (6)hold the octave → 7–6
14, beat 1F♯ (6/5) → G (5/3)hold the 3rd → 9–8
hold the 5th of the 6/5 → 4–3
15, beat 1C (6/5) → D (5/3)hold the 5th → 4–3
hold the 3rd → 9–8

4. Choose a few

Don’t use every place. Choose a few, mostly at cadences and over a rising bass, where the suspension pulls the music forward.

Example 4. Seven suspensions, none before bar 6. In bar 6 the top voice’s E, held from beat 1, becomes a 9th when the bass moves to D, and resolves to the octave. Then 4–3 at the cadences in bars 7, 9 and 10 (in bar 9 the D is prepared by repeating it, and the 4 of the 6/4 is held until beat 4). In bar 11 both upper voices have a 7–6 as the bass climbs E–F♯, and bar 12 ends with a 4–3.

Rules to check:

  • The dissonance falls on a strong beat. The preparation is the same note just before it, tied or repeated, on a weaker beat or across the barline.
  • The resolution goes down by step. It can come late, but it always comes.
  • Don’t sound the note of resolution in another voice against the dissonance. (In a 9–8 the bass has it; that is the exception.)
  • A suspension in an inner voice counts just as much as one in the top voice.

5. Then diminish, around the resolution

Suspensions come after choosing the pattern and before diminishing it (see the Guide to Diminution, “Before you decorate: add suspensions”). When you diminish, the resolution is the goal: decorate on the way to it and around it, and don’t move the suspended note itself.

Example 5. Three voices (after Remeš): a different choice of suspensions, and some diminution. Seven suspensions: a 7–6 at every rising step that starts a Rule of the Octave run (bars 2, 4, 11, 12), the 9–8 of bar 6 (here in the inner voice), and 4–3 in bars 7 and 9. Three of them are in the inner voice.
Example 6, bars 10–12 of Example 5. In bar 11 the resolution, C, gets a lower neighbor (C–B–C). In bar 12 the suspension and its resolution share one beat in eighth notes.

6. From realization to invention

Example 7 keeps the bass and folds the two upper voices of Example 5 into one line of sixteenths: a single melody that carries two voices. Compare the same bars:

Example 7a. Example 5, bars 2–4: two upper voices, with a 7–6 in the alto (bar 2) and in the top voice (bar 4).
Example 7b. The invention, bars 2–4.

On each beat the first sixteenth takes one voice, and the other three circle the other voice’s note with its lower neighbor. In bar 2 the first sixteenths of beats 3 and 4 are the top voice (C, D), and the circled note is the alto’s G, an octave higher: G–F♯–G is its 7–6, now on every beat. In bar 4 the voices swap. The first sixteenths (G, A) are the alto, and the circled note is the top voice’s suspended D with its resolution, C♯. The suspensions don’t disappear in the invention: they become its motive.

Example 7. The whole invention.

Appoggiaturas

An appoggiatura is a note on the beat, dissonant against the underlying chord, that is approached by leap (or after a rest) and resolves by step, up or down, to a chord tone. The dissonant note is an accented non-chord tone; the note it resolves to is the chord tone it delays. Unlike a suspension, it is not prepared: the note before it is a different pitch.

Appoggiaturas are easiest to see over a figured bass, because the figures tell you which notes belong to the chord. In Example 8 the violins and viola play the melody in unison, and the figures are under the continuo (red = dissonance, green = resolution).

Bach, BWV 140, movement 4, bars 1 to 4, with two appoggiaturas marked
Example 8. Bach, Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme (BWV 140), movement 4, “Zion hört die Wächter singen”, bars 1–4. The violins and viola are in alto clef. Bar 1, beat 3: the figure 8/5/3 asks for E♭–G–B♭, but the violins leap up from F to A♭, a 4th above the bass, and fall to G. Bar 2, beat 3: over a plain E♭ chord they leap up from G to D and rise to E♭. One appoggiatura falls, the other rises.

Why does Bach write 8/5/3 at all? A chord on E♭ right after another chord on E♭ needs no figure. He writes it out to cancel the 7/4/2 and to tell the keyboard player to play G, the 3rd, under the violins’ A♭. The figure itself says that the A♭ is not part of the chord.

An appoggiatura usually turns back against the leap, but not always. In Bach’s Sinfonia in F minor (BWV 795), bar 2, B♭ leaps up to E♮, which rises to F. Bach’s own ornament table, written for his son Wilhelm Friedemann in 1720, shows both kinds: accent steigend (rising) and accent fallend (falling). Baroque writers used the word more broadly than we do: their appoggiaturas could also repeat the previous note or arrive by step. In the Guide to Diminution the appoggiatura is part of model 7, Displacement.

Practice

Handel’s partimenti in Monteverdi Academy, one dissonance each. Realize each one plainly first, then check every suspension against the table.

  • Unit A5: Handel, Partimento 10, 4–3 suspensions (F major)
  • Unit A4: Handel, Partimento 15, 7–6 suspensions (A major)
  • Unit A10: Handel, Partimento 17, 9–8 suspensions (C minor)
  • Unit A9: Handel, Partimento 14, 4/2 chords (D major). Here the bass is suspended: the 2nd, which this page leaves out.

Sources

  • Fedele Fenaroli, Regole musicali per i principianti di cembalo (Naples, 1775), the chapters on dissonances and on the suspensions of the 4th, 7th and 9th; Italian–English edition by Robert O. Gjerdingen.
  • Derek Remeš, ed., Handel’s Thoroughbass Exercises.
  • J. S. Bach, Cantata BWV 140, movement 4, bars 1–4 (Example 8); Bach-Gesellschaft Ausgabe, Band 28, ed. Wilhelm Rust (Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, 1881).
  • Realizations: Avner Dorman. Example 5 after Remeš.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *