In Baroque counterpoint—particularly in fugues and chorale Vorimitation—nearly every thematic entry concludes with a clausula. To prevent the music from stalling at every phrase boundary, composers systematically use cadential evasion (cadenza sfuggita) to sustain forward momentum until the final structural close.
Eight Forms of Cadential Evasion (Remeš / Muffat / Walther)
Click any row in the table or click the colored buttons below to expand the music notation and listen to the audio example:
| # | Evasion Technique | Voice | Timing | Mode | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ③ in bass (Alto clausula in bass) | Bass | At ULT | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 2 | ♯③ in any voice (Major third → 7 to the 4th degree) | Any | At ULT | Minor only | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 3 | Holds over to create syncopatio at ULT | Any | At ULT | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 4 | Discant resolves to ♭7 at PEN (Motivo di cadenza) | Discant | At PEN | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 5 | ⑥ in bass (Cadenza finta) | Bass | At ULT | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 6 | Elided subject entry before/at ULT | Entering | PEN / ULT | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 7 | Rest omits ULT pitch (Tacet) | Resolving | At ULT | Major / Minor | Jump to Score ↓ |
| 8 | Discant arrives on ♯1 (→ 7 to the 2nd degree) | Discant | At ULT | Major only | Jump to Score ↓ |
1. ③ in Bass at ULT (Alto Clausula in Bass) ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: The bass descends from ⑤ to ③ at the ULT position (passing through ④ as a transitus) instead of leaping down to ①. In effect, the bass adopts the alto clausula (5-4-3).
Result: Arrives on a 6/3 chord on the 3rd scale degree, avoiding an arrival on the 1st scale degree in the bass and keeping the bassline in motion. (Described by J. G. Walther, 1732).
2. ♯③ in Any Voice at ULT (Minor Mode Only) ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: The cadence arrives on the 1st scale degree in the bass, but sounds the major third (tertia major, F♯ in D minor) in the soprano instead of the expected minor third.
Result: Rather than closing with a static major third, this note immediately functions as the leading tone (7) to the 4th scale degree (G minor), introducing a new chromatic drive to launch the next phrase.
3. Pitch Suspended at ULT to Make Syncopatio ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: The bass holds over its pitch across the barline into the ULT beat, creating an unresolved suspension dissonance at the point of arrival.
Result: Forms a 4–3 syncopatio over the 3rd scale degree (G resolving to F against D in the upper voices), denying rhythmic repose and maintaining continuous forward drive.
4. Discant Resolves to ♭7 at PEN: Motivo di Cadenza ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: This evasion occurs before the arrival (at the PEN position). The suspended discant clausula does not resolve to the raised leading tone (C♯), but drops a chromatic semitone to the lowered ♭7 (C♮).
Result: Walther (1732, p. 425) terms this a motivo di cadenza—a phrase that begins as a cadence but dissolves into a 7/5/3 chord on the 1st scale degree (D–F♯–A–C), steering toward a cadence on the 4th degree (G minor) before the cadence can close.
5. ⑥ in Bass at ULT (Cadenza Finta) ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: The upper voices execute standard discant and tenor clausulae, but the bass steps up from ⑤ to ⑥ (B♭ in D minor) instead of leaping to ①.
Result: The historical cadenza finta (feigned cadence) arriving on a 5/3 chord on the 6th scale degree. Remeš emphasizes that historical evasion includes a much broader toolkit than just this single formula.
6. Elided Subject Entry Before or at ULT ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: A new voice enters with the fugue subject just before or precisely at the cadential resolution.
Result: The initiating energy of the new subject entry overrides the metric and clausular punctuation of the cadence, rendering the arrival seamless.
7. Rest Omits ULT Pitch of Clausula (Tacet) ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: One of the resolving voices drops out at the arrival beat, replacing the expected resolution note with a rest.
Result: Withholding the resolution note leaves the clausula incomplete, clearing acoustic space for that voice to re-enter immediately with a running subject entry.
8. Discant Arrives on ♯1 at ULT (Major Mode Only) ▼ Click to View Score & Play
Mechanism: Applicable only to major keys. At the ULT position, the discant clausula resolves not to 1, but to ♯1 (C♯ in C major).
Result: ♯1 immediately functions as the leading tone to the 2nd scale degree (D minor), modulating up a whole step from the main key.
Source & Further Reading: Adapted from Derek Remeš, Thoroughbass Pedagogy in the Circle of J. S. Bach (Ph.D. diss., Hochschule für Musik Freiburg, 2020), Vol. 1, pp. 311–313, Example 3.3. Grounded in primary sources by Georg Muffat (Regulae concentuum partiturae, 1699) and Johann Gottfried Walther (Musicalisches Lexicon, 1732). Available online at derekremes.com.
Source & Further Reading: Adapted from Derek Remeš, Thoroughbass Pedagogy in the Circle of J. S. Bach (Ph.D. diss., Hochschule für Musik Freiburg, 2020), Vol. 1, pp. 311–313, Example 3.3. Grounded in primary sources by Georg Muffat (Regulae concentuum partiturae, 1699) and Johann Gottfried Walther (Musicalisches Lexicon, 1732). Available online at derekremes.com.
1 Comment