Baroque composers conceptualized moving between keys through the hexachordal system and voice-leading patterns. By altering a single pitch—frequently through a suspension or a cadential leading tone (subsemitonium)—a voice-leading pattern can mutate naturally into an adjacent hexachord to establish a new key center.
Let us examine how our core voice-leading patterns mutate between hexachords to achieve modulation.
1. Descending 7–6 Sequence: Mutating to the Hard Hexachord (G)
We start with the descending 7–6 sequence:
The historical solmization of the bass descent begins fa–mi–re–ut (C–B–A–G) in the hard hexachord on G (hexachordum durum: G–A–B♮–c–d–e). In the full 8-measure sequence in C, the bass continues through F–E–D–C (fa–mi–re–ut in the natural hexachord on C). But because the first four measures already descend to G as ut, we can stop there to cadence on G. Introducing F♯ in the middle voice supplies the subsemitonium (leading tone to G, via musica ficta) to form a cadence on G:
Or with the voices inverted:
This interprets the bass line B–A–G as a tenor clausula in G major (scale degrees 3–2–1), supported by a leaping bass clausula (D–G = 5–1) that confirms the arrival on G.
2. Ascending 5–6 Sequence: Mutating to the Soft Hexachord (F)
Could we do the same thing with a rising 5–6 sequence?
The first four bass notes C–D–E–F (ut–re–mi–fa in the natural hexachord) correspond to scale degrees 5–6–7–8 in F major. By introducing B♭ in the middle voice, the passage mutates into the soft hexachord on F (hexachordum molle: F–G–A–B♭–c–d), cadencing naturally on F:
3. From Hexachords to the Musical Circle: Heinichen’s Ambitus Modi
How did 16th-century hexachordal mutation evolve into 18th-century Baroque modulation? The direct link is Johann David Heinichen’s concept of the Ambitus modi (1728).1
For Heinichen, the Ambitus modi defined the five natural modulatory goals of any key (those differing by at most one accidental):
- The relative key (A minor from C major)
- The fifth degree and its relative (G major and E minor, accessed via the hard hexachord)
- The fourth degree and its relative (F major and D minor, accessed via the soft hexachord)
Heinichen arranged all 24 keys into his famous Musical Circle (Circulus musicus, 1711/1728), where adjacent keys alternate between relative major and minor. This circle replaced the church modes and gave organists and composers a practical improvisational roadmap: when composing or preluding, move to adjacent keys in the circle or skip at most one key. This system is the engine behind the pattern preludes we will explore in the next lesson.
4. Common Modulation Strategies
Below are four foundational Baroque modulatory strategies realized in three voices, complete with thoroughbass figures and playback.
Practice in Monteverdi Academy (Unit B15)
Put hexachordal mutation and modulatory sequence patterns into practice at the keyboard:
Practice Hexachordal Mutation & Modulation in Monteverdi Academy →
1 Johann David Heinichen, Der General-Bass in der Composition (Dresden, 1728), pp. 745–747; see also Derek Remeš, Thoroughbass Pedagogy in the Circle of J. S. Bach (Ph.D. diss., Hochschule für Musik Freiburg, 2020), §1.2.5.