J. S. Bach · Sinfonia 9 in F minor, BWV 795 · Lament bass

Sinfonia 9 in F minor

On the lament pages the chromatic descent from ① to ⑤ sits in the bass. In this sinfonia Bach makes it one of three lines that can go in any voice: the lament (F–E–E♭–D–D♭–C), a sigh line (a rest, then falling pairs of eighths), and a running line in sixteenths and thirty-seconds. They are written in triple counterpoint, which is invertible counterpoint in three voices: any of the three can be on top, in the middle or in the bass.

Below are the first three statements. The voices trade places, but the chord on each beat stays the same. Only the bass changes, and with it the figures. Bach wrote no figures for this piece; these are a reading, after Stoia (2015).

What makes it work: harmony and rhythm

Harmony. On each beat all three lines fit one chord, apart from the sigh line’s appoggiaturas, which resolve into it. Any of the lines can therefore be the bass. Moving a line to the bass changes the figure, not the chord.

Rhythm. Each line has its own rhythmic profile, so all three remain distinct in any voice:

LineRhythmic profileNotes in six beats
LamentQuarter notes, one on every beat6
Sigh lineEighth notes, each group after an eighth rest9
Running lineSixteenths and thirty-seconds, each group after an eighth rest15

The rests interlock. From bar 3, beat 1 to bar 4, beat 2, the sigh line rests on beats 1 and 3 and the running line on beats 2 and 4, while the lament sounds on every beat. Bars 7–8 do the same. Because each rhythm belongs to its line, the pattern survives when the voices trade places.

The sigh line in two strands

The sigh line is one voice, but it moves like two. Its lower strand climbs by step through the sighs, F–G–A♮–B♭, then falls C–B♭–A♭ into the cadence. Its upper strand enters on the high F in bar 2, and ends F–E–F. In the scores the upper strand has stems up, the lower strand stems down.

Bars 1–3

Soprano: rests · Alto: sigh line · Bass: lament

Engraved by Verovio 6.3.0-425dd7b 1 1 4 2 2 1 6 2 5 1 n 4 2 2 2 1 6 1 6 1 6 2 4 1 7 2 n 3 3

Two voices only; the running line enters in bar 3. The figures are Stoia’s. Each sigh starts on a note outside the chord that resolves by step: A♭ to G, B♭ to A♮, E♮ up to F. Over the bass C in bar 2, the high F should fall to E and then rise to F, but Bach does not write the E here (in parentheses).

Bars 3–5

Soprano: sigh line · Alto: lament · Bass: running line

Engraved by Verovio 6.3.0-425dd7b 3 1 n 6 2 5 1 7 2 n 5 3 n 3 1 n 6 2 4 3 3 4 1 n 6 2 4 1 6 1 7 2 n 5 3 n 3 5

The same chords a fifth higher, in C minor. Now the running line is the bass, so the figures change. On beat 2 the bass enters on F under the lament’s C: the chord of bar 1’s 4/2, figured 6/5. At the cadence the alto, done with the lament, writes out what the sigh line only implied: it holds C over the bass G and resolves to B♮, then C.

Bars 7–9

Soprano: lament · Alto: running line · Bass: sigh line

Engraved by Verovio 6.3.0-425dd7b 7 1 7 1 n 6 2 4 3 3 1 6 2 5 8 1 6 2 4 1 7 2 n 3 1 n 1 7 2 n 3 9 1 6 1 6

Back in F minor, and the sigh line is now the bass. Its lower strand F–G–A♮–B♭ is the bass line, and its appoggiaturas (A♭, B♭, E♮) are in the bass: the figures go under the notes they resolve to. The soprano ends the lament and writes out the E: F–E–F.

Same chord, different bass

The nine beats of each statement side by side: the note in the bass, its figure, and the chord. The chords of bars 3–5 are those of bars 1–3 a fifth higher. Beat 1 of bars 3–5 is still the F-minor close of the first statement. Where the bass part rests or runs on a beat, the lowest voice is named.

BeatBars 1–3
lament in the bass
Bars 3–5
lament in the alto
Bars 7–9
lament in the soprano
1F 5/3
F A♭ C
F 5/3
F A♭ C
F 5/3
F A♭ C
2F 4/2
F G B♭ D♭
F ♮6/5
C D F A♭
G 7
F G B♭ D♭
3E 6/5
E G B♭ C
G 7/♮5/♮3
B D F G
G ♮6/4/3
E G B♭ C
4E♭ ♮4/2
E♭ F A C
G ♮6/4/3
B♭ C E G
A 6/5
E♭ F A C
5D 6
D F B♭
C ♮6/4
A C F
B♭ ♮
D F B♭
6D♭ 6
D♭ F B♭
A♭ (alto) 6
A♭ C F
F 6/4
D♭ F B♭
7C 6/4
C F A♭
E♭ 6
G C E♭
F (bass) 5/3
C F A♭
8C 7/♮3
C E G B♭
G 7/♮5/♮3
G B D F
C 7/♮3
C E G B♭
9F 5/3
F A♭ C
C 5/3
C E♭ G
A♭ 6
F A♭ C

The reading of bars 1–3 follows Nicholas Stoia, “Triple Counterpoint and Six-Four Chords in Bach’s Sinfonia in F Minor,” Music Analysis 34/3 (2015): 305–334, Ex. 1b.